Law and Order in Postcolonial Racial Cities The Case of Black Genocide in Rio de Janeiro
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
This work analyzes two class actions contesting the racial violence of Rio de Janeiro’s state police during operations in majority black neighborhoods, assessing both the narratives and social mobilization denouncing black genocide and the role of legal thinking in deviating or denying racism. The analysis of this case reveals that, on the one hand, spatial, racial and juridical structures - established by the racial colonial project and perpetuating in the legacy of racial slavery - create the conditions for genocidal acts to be produced as a long-lasting process. While on the other hand, legal knowledge sustains the “intent to destroy, in whole or in part” a specific group, which is fundamental to the crime of genocide. Considering that black genocide results from institutional racism, the conditions allowing it to happen are not just associated with intent. Black genocide is implemented through the normal functioning of justice institutions, as we discuss in the case study. In this context, black death is central to sustaining power relations, normalized by the use of racial stereotypes for the racialization of space, creating zones of dehumanization as criminality. Denialist discourses use this condition in perpetuity, to normalize genocide and extra-judicial killings. Nonetheless, the concept of institutional racism enables us to understand that genocide can also result from day-to-day decisions taken by politicians, legal professionals, and institutions.
Downloads
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
Works are licensed under Creative Commons license “Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International (CC BY-NC-ND 4.0).”
This license permits readers to share — copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format under the following terms: Attribution — one must give appropriate credit, and provide a link to the license. Non Commercial — one may not use the material for commercial purposes. NoDerivatives — If one remixes, transforms, or builds upon the material, one may not distribute the modified material.
References
Kwame Ture and Charles V. Hamilton, Black Power: The Politics of Liberation in America (Vintage Books 1992).
Peter Fitzpatrick, ‘Racism and the Innocence of Law’ in David Theo Goldberg (ed), Anatomy of Racism (University of Minnesota Press 1990).
Cheryl I Harris, ‘Whiteness as Property’ 106 Harvard Law Review (1993) 1707 <https://doi.org/10.2307/1341787>.
Dora Lúcia Bertúlio, Direito e Relações Raciais: Uma Introdução Crítica Ao Racismo (Lumen Juris 2019);
Ana Luiza Pinheiro Flauzina, Corpo Negro Caído No Chão: O Sistema Penal e o Projeto Genocida Do Estado Brasileiro (1a ed, Contraponto 2008);
Dina Alves, ‘Rés Negras, Juízes Brancos: Uma Análise Da Interseccionalidade de Gênero, Raça e Classe Na Produção Da Punição Em Uma Prisão Paulistana’ [2017] Revista CS 97 <https://doi.org/10.18046/recs.i21.2218>
Sherene Razack, ‘Introduction: When Place Becomes Race’ in Sherene Razack (ed), Race, Space, and the Law: Unmapping a White Settler Society (Between the Lines 2002)
David Delaney, Race, Place and Law (University of Texas Press 1998) 14.
DPERJ v Rio de Janeiro State [2016] TJRJ 0215700-68.2016.8.19.0001 [2019] DJRJ 1940.
PSB v Rio de Janeiro State [2020] STF ADPF 635, [2020] DJe 267.
Rede Observatório de Segurança, ‘A Cor Da Violência Policial: A Bala Não Erra o Alvo’ (2020).
Instituto de Pesquisa Econômica Aplicada (IPEA), ‘Atlas Da Violencia v.2.7 - 2020’ (2020).
Carlos Araújo, Public Defender, Rio de Janeiros, Public Defender’s Office, (Rio de Janeiro, 18 December 2018).
ADI 3.943 CONAMP v Republic Presidency [2018], STF DJE 153 01/08/2018).
Redes da Maré. Boletim ‘Direito à Segurança Pública na Maré’ (2017) <https://www.redesdamare.org.br/media/downloads/arquivos/BoletimSegPublica_2017.pdf>, accessed on 13.04.2021.
Carlos Araújo, Public Defender, Rio de Janeiros, Public Defender’s Office, (Rio de Janeiro, 18 December 2018).
Jaime A Alves and João Costa Vargas, ‘The Spectre of Haiti: Structural Antiblackness, the Far-Right Backlash and the Fear of a Black Majority in Brazil’ (2020) 41 Third World Quarterly 645.
Carlos Araújo, Public Defender, Rio de Janeiros, Public Defender’s Office, (Rio de Janeiro, 18 December 2018).
Carla Lúcia, Public Defender, Rio de Janeiros, Public Defender’s Office, (Rio de Janeiro, 26 February, 2019).
DPERJ v Rio de Janeiro State [2016] TJRJ 0215700-68.2016.8.19.0001 [2019] DJRJ 1940, 40.
Leo Kuper, ‘Theories of Genocide.’ (1981) 4 Journal of Ethnic and Racial Studies.
Charles R Lawrence III, ‘The Id, the Ego, and Equal Protection: Reckoning with Unconscious Racism’ (1987) 39 Stanford Law Review 317; Peggy Cooper Davis, ‘Law as Microagression’ (1989) 98 Yale Law Journal.
Alfred Gell, Art and Agency: An Anthropological Theory (1998); Nick Enfield, ‘Distribution of Agency’ in Nick Enfield and Paul Kockelman (eds), Distributed Agency (Oxford University Press 2017).
Carla Lúcia, Public Defender, Rio de Janeiro, Public Defender’s Office, (Rio de Janeiro, 26 February, 2019).
DPERJ v Rio de Janeiro State [2016] TJRJ 0215700-68.2016.8.19.0001 [2019] DJRJ 1940, 2.
Palloma Menezes, ‘O Problema Da Aproximação No “Policiamento de Proximidade”’ [2018] Trabajo y sociedad: Indagaciones sobre el empleo, la cultura y las prácticas políticas en sociedades segmentadas, ISSN-e 1514-6871, No. 31, 2018, págs. 51-73 51.
Luiza Nobre, Public Attorney, Public Attorney’s Office, (online interview, 17 April 2019).
Ana Luiza Pinheiro Flauzina, ‘Corpo Negro Caído No Chão: O Sistema Penal e o Projeto Genocida do Estado Brasileiro’ (Mester in Law, Universidade de Brasília UNB 2006).
Saidiya V Hartman, Scenes of Subjection: Terror, Slavery, and Self-Making in Nineteenth-Century America (Oxford University Press 1997) 24.
Vera Malaguti Batista, O Medo Na Cidade Do Rio de Janeiro: Dois Tempos de Uma História (Editora Revan 2003) 32.
‘Caso Marielle e Anderson: PM reformado e ex-PM são presos suspeitos do crime’ (G1) <https://g1.globo.com/rj/rio-de-janeiro/noticia/2019/03/12/policia-prende-suspeitos-pelos-assassinatos-da-vereadora-marielle-franco-e-anderson-gomes.ghtml> (accessed 17 June 2021.).
Jaime Amparo Alves, The Anti-Black City: Police Terror and Black Urban Life in Brazil (University of Minnesota Press 2018).
Jaime Amparo Alves, ‘Neither Humans nor Rights: Some Notes on the Double Negation of Black Life in Brazil’ (2014) 45 Journal of Black Studies 143, 146. <https://doi.org/10.1177/0021934714524777>
Dina Alves, ‘Rés Negras, Juízes Brancos: Uma Análise Da Interseccionalidade de Gênero, Raça e Classe Na Produção Da Punição Em Uma Prisão Paulistana’ [2017] Revista CS 97;
Evandro Piza Duarte and Felipe da Silva Freitas, ‘Racism and Drug Policy: Criminal Control and the Management of Black Bodies by the Brazilian State’ in Kojo Koram and ProQuest (Firme), The war on drugs and the global colour line (2019);
Felipe da Silva Freitas, ‘A naturalização da violência racial: escravismo e hiperencarceramento no Brasil’ [2019] Perseu: História, Memória e Política;
Sérgio Adorno, ‘Racismo, Criminalidade Violenta e Justiça Penal: Réus Brancos e Negros Em Perspectiva Comparativa’ (1996) 18 Estudos Históricos, Rio de Janeiro 22.
Luciano Góes, A ‘Tradução’ de Lombroso Na Obra de Nina Rodrigues: O Racismo Como Base Estruturante Da Criminologia Brasileira (Editora Revan 2016).
Marcos V Lustosa Queiroz, Constitucionalismo brasileiro e o Atlântico Negro: a experiência constituinte de 1823 diante da Revolução Haitiana (2nd edn, Lumen Juris 2018).
Vera Malaguti Batista, O Medo Na Cidade Do Rio de Janeiro: Dois Tempos de Uma História (Editora Revan 2003).
PSOL v Federal Union [2020] STF ADPF 347 [2020] DJe-165, 1.
Ana Flauzina and Thula Pires, ‘Supremo Tribunal Federal e a Naturalização Da Barbárie’ (2020) 11 Revista Direito e Práxis 1211. <https://doi.org/10.1590/2179-8966/2020/50270>
Federal Steering Committee of the Juventude Viva Plan - CGJuV was formally instituted through Interministerial Ordinance No. 29, of May 22, 2013.
Secretaria Nacional de Juventude, ‘Plano Juventude Viva: Guia de Implementação Para Estados e Municípios’ (Secretaria Nacional de Juventude (SNJ/SG-PR) 2014).
Secretaria Nacional de Juventude 10.
Silvia Rodríguez Maeso and Marta Araújo, ‘The Semantics of (Anti-)Racism in the Governance of Non-Europeanness: An Introduction’ (2017) 51 Patterns of Prejudice 1. <https://doi.org/10.1080/0031322X.2016.1270499>
Lindbergh Farias, ‘Relatório Final CPI Assassinato de Jovens’ (Senado Federal 2016) Comissão Parlamentar de Inquérito SF/16203.78871-55.
Silvio Almeida, Racismo Estrutural (Djamila Ribeiro ed, Pólen 2019) 115.
Achille Mbembe, ‘Necropolitics’ (2003) 15 Public Culture 11.
Lorreine Carvalho da Silva, ‘“Pacote Anticrime” representa tentativa de aprofundar o racismo antinegro no Brasil’ (Justificando, 29 August 2019) <http://www.justificando.com/2019/08/29/pacote-anticrime-representa-tentativa-de-aprofundar-o-racismo-antinegro-no-brasil/> accessed 17 June 2021.
Jaime A Alves and João Costa Vargas, ‘The Spectre of Haiti: Structural Antiblackness, the Far-Right Backlash and the Fear of a Black Majority in Brazil’ (2020) 41 Third World Quarterly 645 <https://doi.org/10.1080/01436597.2019.1695116>
United Nations General Assembly, Convention on the Prevention and Punishment of the Crime of Genocide 1948.
Kai Ambos, ‘What Does “Intent to Destroy” in Genocide Mean?’ (2009) 91 International Review of the Red Cross 833.
Cheryl I Harris, ‘Whiteness as Property’ (1993) 106 Harvard Law Review 1707, 1762. https://doi.org/10.2307/1341787
APublica journalismt <https://apublica.org/2021/03/brasil-registra-duas-vezes-mais-pessoas-brancas-vacinadas-que-negras/>, accessed on 02.04.2021.
Florestan Fernandes and Roger Bastide, Brancos e Negros Em São Paulo (Global Editora 2015); Florestan Fernandes, O Negro No Mundo Dos Brancos (Global Editora 2015).
Abdias do Nascimento, O Genocídio Do Negro Brasileiro: Processo de um Racismo Mascarado (Paz & Terra ed, 1978) 44-45
Marianne Constable, Leti Volpp and Bryan Wagner (eds), Looking for Law in All the Wrong Places: Justice Beyond and Between (Fordham University Press 2019) 2.
Denise Ferreira da Silva, A Dívida Impagável (Living Commons 2019).
‘“A polícia vai mirar na cabecinha e... fogo”, afirma Wilson Witzel’ <https://noticias.uol.com.br/ultimas-noticias/agencia-estado/2018/11/01/a-policia-vai-mirar-na-cabecinha-e-fogo-afirma-wilson-witzel.htm> accessed 17 June 2021.
PSB v Rio de Janeiro State [2020] STF ADPF 635, [2020] DJe 267, 94.
Cheryl I Harris, ‘Whiteness as Property’ (1993) 106 Harvard Law Review 1707, 1753
Educafro Amicus Curie’s brief, PSB v Rio de Janeiro State [2020] STF ADPF 635, [2020] DJe 267, 24.
PSB v Rio de Janeiro State [2020] STF ADPF 635, [2020] DJe 267, 74.
Evandro Piza Duarte and Felipe da Silva Freitas, ‘Racism and Drug Policy: Criminal Control and the Management of Black Bodies by the Brazilian State’ in Kojo Koram and ProQuest (Firme), The war on drugs and the global colour line (2019).
Kojo Koram, ‘Introduction’ in Kojo Koram (ed), The War on Drugs and the Global Colour Line (Pluto Press 2019).
Gizlene Neder, Iluminismo Jurídico-Penal Luso-Brasileiro: Obediência e Submissão (Instituto Carioca de Criminologia: Freitas Bastos Editora 2000) 15.
Ana Luiza Pinheiro Flauzina, Corpo Negro Caído No Chão: O Sistema Penal e o Projeto Genocida Do Estado Brasileiro (1a ed, Contraponto 2008).
Hattery A and Smith E, Policing Black Bodies: How Black Lives Are Surveilled and How to Work for Change (Updated edition, Rowman & Littlefield 2021);
Cashmore E, Out of Order?: Policing Black People (Routledge 2013) and Weissinger SE, Law Enforcement in the Age of Black Lives Matter: Policing Black and Brown Bodies (Lexington 2017).
TJRJ v Cidadãos e Cidadãs Domiciliados nas Favelas do Jacarezinho e Conjunto Habitacional Morar Carioca [2019] STJ HC n° 435-934-AgR [2019] DJe, 23.
TJRJ v Cidadãos e Cidadãs Domiciliados nas Favelas do Jacarezinho e Conjunto Habitacional Morar Carioca [2019] STJ HC n° 435-934-AgR [2019] DJe, 23.
Vera da Silva Telles, A Cidade Nas Fronteiras Do Legal e Ilegal, vol 25 (Argumentum 2010).
Cidade de Deus (2002) or City of God by Fernando Meirelles and Kátia Lund is a film that addresses violence in the slums of Rio de Janeiro, focusing on the drug trafficking, but picturing the slums as territories of pure barbarism, according to Corrêa, “to reduce a favela to drug trafficking and violence, showing characters with animal stereotypes, is to establish a game of alterity with the spectator.”
Felipe Botelho Corrêa, ‘As Projeções de Alteridade No Espaço Urbano Carioca a Favela No Cinema Brasileiro Contemporâneo’ (2006) 9 Lumina 51, 54.
Felipe Botelho Corrêa, ‘As Projeções de Alteridade No Espaço Urbano Carioca a Favela No Cinema Brasileiro Contemporâneo’ (2006) 9 Lumina 51.
Clóvis Moura, Sociologia Do Negro Brasileiro (2a̲ edição, Perspectiva 2019) 50.
Edward G Goetz, Rashad A Williams and Anthony Damiano, ‘Whiteness and Urban Planning’ (2020) 86 Journal of the American Planning Association 142. <https://doi.org/10.1080/01944363.2019.1693907>
PSB v Rio de Janeiro State [2020] STF ADPF 635, [2020] DJe 267, 14.
Sherene Razack, ‘Introduction: When Place Becomes Race’ in Sherene Razack (ed), Race, Space, and the Law: Unmapping a White Settler Society (Between the Lines 2002) 2.
<http://portal.stf.jus.br/noticias/verNoticiaDetalhe.asp?idConteudo=464270&ori=1>, accessed on 22 April 2021.